This is reminds me that of a second strange pairing that resulted in "That's gross". I was finishing lunch and had extra peanut butter that I was dipping apples in with only carrots remaining. So, I started scooping the PB out of the dish with the carrots. It tasted awesome but again, drew quite a few strange looks.
They aren't things that go together like peanut butter and jelly, cookies and milk or Penn and Teller but for me, they work.
What strange food combinations do you enjoy? What were others' reactions?